|
May a Libertarian Take Money From the Government?by Walter BlockMar. 11, 2011 |
Popular 
Bill Kristol: My Fellow White Americans Are 'The Enemy'
Israel Detains American Journalist for Reporting on Damage from Iran's Strikes [UPDATE]
Journalist Jeremy Loffredo Released After Four Days in Israeli Detention, Ordered Not to Leave
Chris Rufo Discovers Who is Flooding The Small Town of Charleroi, Pennsylvania With Haitian Migrants
WATCH: New Film 'Atrocity Inc' Exposes How Israel Lied About October 7th to Justify Genocide
 "...My take on this is that it is a positive virtue to relieve the government of its ill-gotten gains. Suppose Z steals an apple from Y and then X comes along and takes this fruit away from Z. Did X do anything wrong? Did he act incompatibly with the NAP? Is X no longer a libertarian? Of course not. Very much to the contrary, X did something entirely compatible with our philosophy. Certainly, all libertarian theories of private property rights, of punishment, would agree that of all people in the world, Z is the absolutely least deserving of this foodstuff. Now, it might be nice, it might be virtuous, for X to return the apple to Y..." Read More 
|
